Resolution CM/ResDH(2010)122

Execution of the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights
in 36 cases against France

(see Appendix)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”);

Having regard to the judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee once they had become final,
and following the Court’s finding of violations of the Convention in these cases;

Having invited the government of the respondent state to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with its obligation under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention to abide by the judgments;

Having examined the information provided by the government in accordance with the Committee’s Rules for the application of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention;

Having satisfied itself that the respondent state paid the applicants the just satisfaction provided in the judgments,

Recalling that the general measures required to prevent similar violations to those found by the Court in these cases have already been adopted in leading cases (see the relevant final resolutions cited in the appended table);

Noting furthermore, as the government considers and given the particular circumstances of each case, that no individual measure is necessary apart from the payment of just satisfaction,

DECLARES, having examined the measures taken by the respondent state, that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and

DECIDES to close the examination of these cases.

Appendix to Resolution CM/ResDH(2010)122

Information on the measures taken to comply with the judgments in
36 cases against France

Cases under examination	Reference cases already closed	
Application No	Case name	Date of judgment	Date of final judgment	Reference Final Resolution	
44451/98	A.A.U	19/06/2001	19/09/2001	DH(98)361	
53118/99	Boiseau	19/02/2002	19/05/2002	DH(98)361	
70160/01	AON Conseil and Courtage SA and others	25/01/2007	25/04/2007	ResDH(2006)32	
73893/01	Besseau	07/03/2006	07/06/2006	ResDH(2003)94	
44404/02	Cour	03/10/2006	03/01/2007	CM/ResDH(2008)05	
53425/99	Dumas	23/09/2003	24/03/2004	CM/ResDH(2008)39	
41522/98	Gaultier	28/03/2006	28/06/2006	CM/ResDH(2007)42	
66224/01	Gosselin	13/09/2005	13/12/2005	ResDH(2003)50 and CM/ResDH(2007)39	
348/03	Ong	14/11/2006	14/02/2007	CM/ResDH(2008)05	
23054/03	S.U.	10/10/2006	10/01/2007	CM/ResDH(2007)42	
7217/05	Treboux	03/10/2006	03/01/2007	CM/ResDH(2007)42	
41943/98	L.L. 	07/02/2002	07/05/2002	CM/ResDH(2008)39	
51360/99	Marschner	28/09/2004	28/12/2004	CM/ResDH(2007)39
CM/ResDH(2008)12	
27314/02	Vallar	04/10/2007	04/01/2008	CM/ResDH(2008)38	
68673/01	Mathieu	27/10/2005	27/01/2006	CM/ResDH(2007)42	
38287/02	Van Glabeke	07/03/2006	07/06/2006	CM/ResDH(2007)42	
42272/98	Potier	08/11/2005	08/02/2006	CM/ResDH(2007)39	
52621/99	Schwarkmann	08/02/2005	08/05/2005	CM/ResDH(2007)39	
13324/04	Association Avenir d’Alet	14/02/2008	06/04/2009	CM/ResDH(2007)44	
18130/05	Bochet	10/04/2008	29/09/2008	CM/ResDH(2007)44	
77240/01	CED Viandes and others 	27/07/2006	27/10/2006	CM/ResDH(2007)44	
42122/04	Arouette	24/07/2008	24/10/2008	CM/ResDH(2008)71	
44562/04	Fonfrede	16/10/2008	16/01/2009	CM/ResDH(2008)71	
19/05	Laudette	11/06/2009	11/09/2009	CM/ResDH(2008)13	
36109/03	Leroy	02/10/2008	06/04/2009	CM/ResDH(2008)71	
38984/04	Garnier Rémy 	22/05/2008	29/09/2008	CM/ResDH(2008)71	
21148/02	Garriguenc	10/07/2008	10/10/2008	ResDH(2003)50	
2078/04	Cretello	23/01/2007	23/04/2007	ResDH(2003)50
CM/ResDH(2007)39	
32157/06	Gunes	20/11/2008	20/02/2009	CM/ResDH(2008)12	
59584/00	Rivas	01/04/2004	01/07/2004	CM/ResDH(2009)126	
77655/01	Relais du Min S.A.R.L.	20/12/2005	20/03/2006	CM/ResDH(2008)13	
12876/04	S.C.I Plelo-Cadiou	22/11/2007	02/06/2008	CM/ResDH(2008)13	
3211/05	Vuillemin	19/09/2006	19/12/2006	CM/ResDH(2008)13	
16022/02	Roux 	25/04/2006	25/07/2006	CM/ResDH(2007)79	
12332/03	Castelot	24/04/2008	Friendly settlement	-	
61104/00	Quillevere	27/10/2005	Friendly settlement	-